BALANCING RISK AND REWARD
Managing Investment Risk
Risk is a factor in any investment. We know we’re not going to achieve exactly 8% every year — some years our portfolio will return more, and other years it will earn less, depending on markets.
So what’s an acceptable level of risk? For us, it’s the smallest amount of risk we can take to achieve our goal of an 8% long-term return.
What is Risk?
When making investment decisions, there are two kinds of risk the TCDRS Board of Trustees must be aware of:
- Long-term risk is the possibility that investment return will not be sufficient to grow our assets enough to pay future benefit claims.
- Short-term risk is the possibility of varying returns from year-to-year. Higher returning asset classes tend to be more volatile (or risky) than lower returning asset classes. While their return over longer timeframes may be higher, their year-to-year return will fluctuate more widely.
As a result, our approach to investment risk centers around two main questions:
- Is our portfolio designed to earn enough in returns combined with employer and employee contributions to pay the retirement benefits promised by our employers? (This is long-term risk.)
- Are we comfortable with the potential year-to-year volatility in returns from our current mix of investments and its impact on employer rates? (This is short-term risk.)
Diversification is our primary defense against both long-term and short-term risk.
Investment Risk and Employer Rates
Annual investment returns have a direct impact on employer plan rates because our employers are required by law to pay 100% of their required rate each year. A poor performing year could cause employer rates to increase for the following year.
That’s why we manage risk very closely. Fortunately, we have a great track record of meeting (and exceeding) our performance goals. In addition to managing risk in our portfolio, there are other strategies that both TCDRS and employers can use to keep rates stable.
HOW WE DO IT: THE NUTS AND BOLTS
Currently, the overall TCDRS portfolio has an expected return of 8% with an annual risk of around 12%. For every major asset class we’ve chosen for our portfolio, we expect a certain return and a certain amount of volatility. We use statistical tools, such as standard deviation and correlation, to evaluate asset classes and determine which fit best in our portfolio. While the range of volatility for individual asset classes may extend beyond our risk tolerance, the risk of the entire portfolio is expected to remain within that range.
Expected and Actual Results, 1998 – 2019
Net of All Fees
The gray bar in the graph above represents the amount of risk our portfolio as a whole is designed to operate within — a range of +/-12% centered around our 8% long-term investment goal. With the exception of the great recession and bounce-back of 2008-2009, our investment returns have performed as expected.